To Participate on Thurstonblog

email yyyyyyyyyy58@gmail.com, provide profile information and we'll email your electronic membership


Wednesday, December 31, 2014

"... the faithful increasingly [are] tailoring religion to suit their own sensibilities ..." So who is to say that their sensibilities are any more correct than anyone else's?

...................................................................................................................................................................
COMMENT:  The message of Christianity is immoral and demeaning. We all are born guilty, so the story goes, of something (gaining knowledge from a tree) so terrible that we must accept the primitive, barbaric and immoral sacrifice of another human being in atonement to a supernatural being, a bronze-age war god named Yahweh. Their infallible book glorifies the end of the planet and all of mankind, except them of course, in a religious war allegedly between good and evil. With an unimaginable degree of certainty followers know they will be saved form [i.e. from] this burning planet into a second life in a different perfect place. That perfect life in that perfect place becomes more valued than this life and this place.
...................................................................................................................................................................
Atheism, agnosticism and belief: Thoughts on going with or without God
By Paul Thornton, December 26, 2014

The Times' front-page article Monday on Ryan Bell, a former Seventh-day Adventist minister nearing the end of his "year without God," prompted dozens of readers to ruminate on religion, spirituality, atheism and agnosticism. The handful of letters published on Christmas Day — some encouraging Bell to embrace a less black-and-white version of faith, others advocating for skepticism — prompted more discussion among readers.

As with all conversations religious — and with the faithful increasingly tailoring religion to suit their own sensibilities — the one on Bell's crisis of faith remains ongoing, with letters still streaming in. The reader submissions below continue that discussion.

George Epstein of Los Angeles coins a universal "religion":

The letters responding to the article on Ryan Bell convince me that my concept regarding religion is right on.

Years ago, my then-12-year-old son asked me: "Dad, how do I know there is a God? I can't see him; I can't hear him; I can't touch him." At that moment my own long-term doubts came to mind. Then I realized that the concept of religion, including a God, was created by well-meaning people to help us live together in peace, harmony and justice for all. It's a good concept.

Today, when asked, I tell people, "My religion is conceptualism." As far as others, any form of religion is OK so long as it helps the believers achieve peace, harmony and justice for all. Obviously, with all the turmoil and killing in our world, these haven't been achieved — all the more reason to pursue conceptualism.

Jim Johnson of Whittier finds little use for agnosticism:

Letter writer Judi Birnberg offers agnosticism as "the only tenable position," demonstrating how some people have not learned from logic how to recognize where the burden of proof properly resides.

This inability to distinguish an onus probandi from a hole in the ground (the fallacy known as the argumentum ad ignorantiam) should disqualify people from jury duty, where in criminal cases, they would mistakenly think that they had three voting options: guilty, not guilty and undecided.

And whereas science relies on the null hypothesis, those who advocate agnosticism would perhaps mistakenly think it necessary to spend millions of dollars proving that a potential new drug does not cure cancer. "Who can say with certainty that [God] does not exist?," asks Birnberg, when no such certainty is necessary.

Cathedral City resident Rolf Olson proposes a simple test of belief:

Does it take a year to decide if one is a Christian? Shakespeare advises, "To thine own self be true," which many interpret as the hallmark of honest self reflection resulting in a healthy conscience.

Read the Christian statement of beliefs in the Apostles' Creed. If the reader can then say, with honesty, "Yes, I believe in the reality of these supernatural events and characters," then one is a Christian.
...................................................................................................................................................................

No comments: